The miracle of the Disney-produced fairytale parody Enchanted is that it has one joke and the sheer hubris to run it straight into the ground. By all accounts, it should have run out of steam by the 40-minute mark. Instead, it catches a second wind. Its secret must have been in the balance. On one hand, this is a relentless mocking of fairytales. On the other, it falls a little bit in love with them.
It all starts in a land called Andalasia—a pastel kingdom where woodland creatures do chores, songs erupt without warning, and marriage proposals are about as common as coffee refills. Basically, every Disney reflex crammed into one sugar rush. Giselle (Amy Adams) lives in a treehouse that looks like a vanilla cake exploded inside it. Her dream of marrying Prince Edward (James Marsden) comes easier for her than it is for most people buying a loaf of Wonder Bread. They meet. They sing. She doesn’t even check the expiration date. That’s love.
But there’s trouble. Their wedding’s minutes away when Edward’s stepmother, Queen Narissa (Susan Sarandon), decides that she’s not interested in surrendering her crown—or her magic—both of which will vanish as soon as he marries. So she does what any evil stepmother would: shove the bride down a wishing well that, for reasons best left unexamined, opens straight into Times Square.
Giselle bursts out of a manhole—flesh and blood now—in full wedding regalia, blinking at the neon lights like the city’s been cursed. Yet Giselle’s fairytale optimism crashes headfirst into urban indifference, because she doesn’t know any other way. Of course, all of this is hysterical thanks to Adams, who never drops the act. She’s so sincere, even, that you stop laughing at her and start believing her.
An intuitive little girl (Rachel Covey) eventually spots this lost, luminous princess and brings her home to her dad, Robert (Patrick Dempsey)—although he probably wishes (at first, anyway) that she’d brought home a mange-ridden cat. He reluctantly lets her stay, but at the back of his mind is probably deciding who he should call first should things get out of hand: a therapist, a priest, or pest control.
Pest control might have been his best bet, although he (nor anyone else) has ever seen pests do quite what Giselle has them do. In what’s easily the film’s most memorable scene, she calls for bluebirds and butterflies to help clean Robert’s apartment, but Manhattan instead sends rats, pigeons, and cockroaches. Close enough—they not only get the job done, but they have a song and choreography to go with it. Meanwhile, Robert’s girlfriend, Nancy (Idina Menzel), watches in disbelief as her boyfriend starts his inevitable journey of falling for a woman who talks to pigeons.
The movie takes on predictable plot beats from there. Naturally, the love triangles you’ve noticed forming start to sharpen. There’s exactly the third-act danger you’re expecting. And then happily ever after. But this is a movie that plays by the rules while also poking fun at them—you’re laughing at it and quietly believing in it, too.
And there’s no doubt princess-obsessed little ones loved this enough to watch it until the DVD melts. Parents probably found themselves laughing more than they meant to. And for everyone else—those half-wary of Disney’s sugar rush—there’s a good reason to at least let this one drift through the living room some evening. It believes in true love, but only after watching it trip over a turnstile.