A thriller that doesn’t thrill. A 99-minute heel-dragger that’s glossy, atmospheric, and slick, but its pacing is so half-baked and its pulse so inert that all we get in the end is a stylish husk.
Katie Holmes plays Katie, a graduate student who is supposedly buckling under intense academic pressure—though you’d never guess that based on the film’s glassy tone and Holmes’ underplayed performance. Her breakdown takes the form of visions of her vanished ex-boyfriend Embry (Charlie Hunnam)—a smug golden boy who disappeared without a trace years earlier. Now he suddenly appears to her in fleeting visions—in corridors, cafeterias, lecture halls. She has no time to react. As soon as she blinks, he’s gone.
That’s a fine set-up—eerie enough. But all we get is a film that staggers from scene to scene, searching for suspense the way a drunk searches for his keys—blindly, aimlessly, and with little hope. Of course, there’s the inevitable twist, but it feels so flimsy and inane that you can’t even be bothered to laugh at it. It’s the same way you wouldn’t laugh at someone trying to shoot a bullet through a sheet of toilet paper, convinced that it won’t just tear right through.
The detective assigned to investigate the case is played by Benjamin Bratt with about as much urgency as a man waiting for his coffee to cool. He eventually pieces together that maybe Katie isn’t imagining all this after all. While Katie Holmes’ performance leaves much to be desired, I’d blame the script for that much sooner than Holmes herself. She projects a sort of natural nervous energy, but the film has no idea what to do with it. The supporting players—Zooey Deschanel shows up as (what else?) a sardonic classmate—aren’t much better off. They’re left stranded, floating around a story that can’t figure out how to use them.
While there’s some slick cinematography here—streets glowing under silvery dusk, fluorescent lights blanketing the library’s interior with an eerie hum—this beauty without tension ultimately leaves me empty. It’s like being stuck inside a designer showroom. Plenty to look at, but nothing for sale.