It starts like a romance. Two people, a few jokes, a splash of something golden that catches the light in an enthralling way. It’s innocent, even sweet. But then somewhere between that first toast and the final hangover, the bottle becomes the only thing that’s holding them together. That is, until it becomes the thing that’s tearing them apart.
Joe Clay (Jack Lemmon) sells charm and keeps a bottle close to fake it. Kirsten Arnesen (Lee Remick) is careful, gentle, curious. She tries a sip—a brandy Alexander. “It’s chocolate,” he says. She believes him. That’s all it takes.
For a while, they sparkle. Love and liquor make quick friends. They marry. They drink. The world turns gauzy, every emotion answered by another glass. Then come the longer nights, the blurred mornings. The laughter dulls. The collection of empty bottles seems to multiply. The marriage begins to rot like fruit left out on the counter too long.
Joe sinks first. The office suit turns damp, the grin goes slack. He drinks through the day, sweats through the night, and loses the job that kept the illusion going. Kirsten trails behind—less visibly, more gracefully—but her drop is steeper. Her sweetness fades into vacancy. Her gaze drifts. And when either of them realizes what’s happened, the damage is done. The drinking that had once bound them together has become what’s tearing them apart.
Lemmon’s performance is so raw it almost feels like trespassing. Late in the film, Joe tears through a greenhouse. He thinks he hid a bottle into one of the dozens of potted plants that are there. One by one he claws frantically through them, through soil and foliage, like he’s trying to unearth the last piece of whatever was left of his soul. What a difficult scene to watch. Especially if you’ve ever seen yourself—or anyone you love—in such a low place. Remick’s fall is quieter. Somehow that makes it worse. He wears the madness on his skin for everyone to see, but she swallows the grief whole.
Jack Klugman shows up as Joe’s AA sponsor, a man who’s seen too many wrecks to mistake survival for redemption. Charles Bickford, as Kirsten’s father, gives the film its backbone as a man left to watch helplessly as his daughter drifts into a fog he can’t clear.
Blake Edwards, known more for letting Peter Sellers trip over furniture in his comedies, moves differently here. There’s no reach for humor. He even avoids sermonizing or letting this slip into melodrama. He stages addiction such that it feels routine. And the effect is rough and even vaguely documentary-like. Ultimately, this is a film that understands how easy the slide can feel at first and how impossible the climb back becomes.