On paper, this is a romantic comedy. In practice, this is a barbed character piece. One that slips in and waffles between cringe and sentiment without settling into either. Jack Nicholson plays Melvin Udall, a man so proudly unpleasant that he treats decency as though it’s a personality flaw. He’s every brand of offensive: racist, sexist, homophobic, and just plain rude. And with no filter, either. Everything that slithers out of his mouth is delivered with such relish that you wonder if he’s competing with himself to find new lows.
Melvin also has other obstacles, most of them self-inflicted, while others are more hardwired. He has obsessive-compulsive disorder and lives like he’s navigating a minefield of rituals. Every step has to be rehearsed, every meal is identical. He eats breakfast at the same diner, at the same table, served by the same waitress—Carol (Helen Hunt), who happens to be the only person patient enough to tolerate him. Or maybe she’s just stubborn enough not to let anyone force her to bolt out the door. He’s clearly besotted with her, but his idea of affection is a compliment, and even those still somehow feel like a slap.
Across the hall of Melvin’s apartment is Simon (Greg Kinnear), a soft-spoken gay artist who often bears the brunt of Melvin’s hostility. But then there’s a brutal turn of events that leaves Simon hospitalized, and through a perverse twist of fate, Melvin ends up looking after Simon’s dog—the same creature that he once shoved down a garbage chute. That’s when something shifts in Melvin. Not a miracle, not even a revelation—just a fracture in the routine. Feed the dog. Walk the dog. Let it crawl into your lap and remind you, against your will, that connection isn’t optional. Melvin doesn’t transform; he erodes. Enough to let a little light through the cracks.
Jack Nicholson turns razor edges and sudden retreats into brittle charm, a performance so compelling that he earned his third acting Oscar. Hunt earned one as well, adorning her Carol with a blend of weariness and defiance—a woman who still believes in people, even when she should know better. Kinnear is gentle but never soft and finds dignity in a role that could’ve been little more than a punching bag. And then there’s Cuba Gooding Jr. as Simon’s fiery art dealer. His feet are planted so firmly in the real world that you half expect him to reach through the screen and shake everyone by the collar.
As Good as It Gets isn’t a movie about grand redemption arcs. It’s about attrition. You watch it to see someone chip away at their own armor just enough to let someone in. This is a movie that’s sharp, funny, romantic, and awkward. Infectiously watchable. As far as romantic comedies go, you might say this one is about as good as it gets.