Albert Brooks plays Robert Cole—a man coming apart in real time. Not with fireworks but with sighs, backpedals, and half-apologies. He edits movies for a living—taking little cut-up moments gathered in a film shoot and reassembling them in optimal ways. But when he goes home, the cuts don’t line up. He can’t trim the mistakes, can’t reshoot the scene. What he—or any of us—wouldn’t give just for a rewind button?
Early on, Robert breaks up with his girlfriend—calmly, clinically, as if the pain will hurt less if he controls the incision. He’s decided no one should have to deal with him, least of all her. So he’s doing her a favor. It’s the mature thing to do. But that conviction lasts maybe five minutes. After that, he’s at war with himself—jealousy, guilt, regret, projection—on rotation. It’s like watching someone reread their own bad diary entries in real time. And he drags everyone within reach into it. Especially his ex-girlfriend. Or his ex-ex-girlfriend. Whatever version of their relationship he’s decided they’re in at that particular moment.
There’s a moment in this film when he drops a fortune on a full home gym. He’s convinced this will be the thing that fixes everything. The reset button his life’s been waiting for. And maybe it could’ve been. But he quits before breaking a sweat. Robert isn’t lazy. He’s just hooked to the fantasy of quick fixes.
When Robert is not spiraling romantically, he’s holed up in his editing room, cutting a cheap sci-fi flick while dispensing smug advice to the director. I particularly enjoy these scenes—at least as a film buff. They are partly satire but also provide some real insight into the film editing process. These scenes are little miracles—tweaking sound effects, splicing reels, fussing over insignificant detail. It’s a rare peek into the guts of post-production.
Modern Romance isn’t a breakup story. It’s more like a slow-motion autopsy in self-sabotage. While every decision that Robert makes has its own logic, it’s that accumulation of decisions that kills him. What Brooks nails here is a kind of masculine neurosis that most films aren’t willing to touch—something he doesn’t just make watchable here, but makes very, very funny.